Being a parent is hard work, and new research shows that many parenting strategies are scientifically proven to fail. Alan Kazdin, a psychologist at the Yale Parenting Center and Child Conduct Clinic gives eight examples of how well-intentioned parents fail at disciplining their children. His research is summarized by Nancy Shute in US News and World Report.
According to Kazdin, “It's intuitive to scream at your child to change their behavior, even though the research is unequivocal that it won't work.” Other examples of discipline strategies that do not work are:
1. Parents Fail to Set Limits
Children who do not have limits have proven more defiant and rebellious than those who do. In the absence of limits, children feel unsafe and push to see whether their parents respond.
Columbia University Teachers College psychologist Suniya Luthar reported in 2003 that children who are indulged with advantages are more likely to be anxious, depressed, and abuse drugs and alcohol than those who are not.
Giving simple, clear commands and being consistent are keys in setting limits. Parents may let children choose between two acceptable choices, such as “A half-hour of Nintendo right after school, then homework? Or, “Finish all homework before game time?”
Mother, Lauren Jordan says that she has “to be very strict with [herself] and go over and tell [her son] the rules and walk away.” Parents know that isn’t always easy, but this consistency pays off and can make a home a much happier place.
2. Parents are overprotective
"Many well-meaning parents jump in too quickly," says Robert Brooks, a clinical psychologist in Needham, Mass., and coauthor of Raising Resilient Children. "Resilient children realize that sometimes they will fail, make mistakes, have setbacks. They will attempt to learn from them."
Brooks goes on to say that parental intervention “communicates to the kid that 'I don't think you're capable of dealing with it.' We have to let kids experience the consequences of their behavior." If not, they may be afraid to try and afraid to fail.
3. Parents nag, lecture, repeat, and then yell.
Abundant evidence exists to prove that humans tune out repeated commands. Lynn Clark, professor emeritus of psychology at Western Kentucky University and author of SOS Help for Parents says that "So many parents think they have to get very emotionally upset, yell, threaten, use sarcasm. The child imitates that behavior, and you get sassy talk."
Nagging doesn’t work, either; it gives children an incentive – parental attention – to keep misbehaving. Mother of 9-year-old-Nick, Nancy Ailes, says she “was kind of ignoring the good behavior, and every time he did something wrong, I would step in and give him attention." She was frustrated with her son, who would melt down if the day’s schedule changed and call her a “bad Mommy” if she complained.
4. Parents praise too much—and badly
While it seems intuitive that praise would make children feel good about themselves and act as a motivator, parents don’t praise children as often as they think. Praise that is generic (“good job!”) or is centered on the child (“you’re so smart!”) and not the task, actually works to make a child less motivated and self-confident. An experiment by Carol Dweck, now a psychologist at Stanford University, found that fifth graders who were praised for being intelligent, rather than for making a good effort, had a harder time dealing with failure and made less of an effort on tests.
5. Parents punish too harshly
According to Murray Straus, professor of psychology at the University to New Hampshire, as many as 90 percent of parents think spanking young children is okay.
Jamilia Reid, co director of the Parenting Clinic at the University of Washington says that “Often parents come looking for bigger sticks. We tell parents the word discipline means 'teach.' It's something to teach a child that there's a better way to respond."
Key findings about research into time-out as a disciplinary strategy shows that discipline that is immediate, mild, and brief,, works best.
Teens who have outgrown timeouts and instead have privileges revoked shouldn’t lose a privilege for more than a day, because after that, the child’s attitude shifts from the behavior to resentment of parents.
Kazdin says this “puts a little wedge in the relationship between parent and child," and that it is better to ask the child to practice good behavior to win back privileges.
6. Parents Tell their Children How to Feel
Many studies show that empathy for others is a top quality that people need to be successful in relationships, and children need to think about others’ feelings as well as how their own feelings are affected by what they do. Myrna Shure, a developmental psychologist at Drexel University and author of Raising a Thinking Child, says "That is what will inhibit a child from hurting others, either physically or emotionally."
If parents tell children you're fine" or "don't cry," they don’t let children have a chance to learn these lessons. "The child learns empathy through being empathized with," says Stanley Greenspan, a child psychiatrist in Chevy Chase, Maryland. Greenspan’s book Great Kids helps parents help their children to develop 10 essential qualities for a happy life; empathy is on the top of the list.
"Modeling empathic behavior is really very important," too, according to James Windell, a counselor with the juvenile court system in Oakland County, Michigan. "How you respond to your children's needs sets the stage."
7. Parents put Grades and SATs Ahead of Creativity
Overemphasizing good grades can give a distorted message about how and what children learn. "We like kids to learn rules, and we want them to learn facts," says Greenspan. "We're impressed when they can read early or identify their shapes. It's much harder for us to inspire them to come up with a creative idea."
Creative thinkers are more likely to be able to “bounce back if their first idea doesn't work” and know that a good solution takes time and patience to reach. Greenspan says the goal is to have a child who grows up to ask the important questions, not to have one who knows how to answer the questions.
To help children become independent thinkers, parents can ask open-ended questions like “Can you think of another way to solve the problem with your teammate?”
8. Parents Forget to Have Fun
Robert Hendren, a professor of psychiatry at the Medical Investigation of Neurodevelopmental Disorders Institute at the University of California-Davis and president of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, says that "When I talk to families that aren't functioning so well, and I ask, how often do you laugh together, they say: ‘We haven't laughed together for a long time.’”
Hendren says that little signs of love and connection, of sharing a song or a laugh, are signs of health.